To Spank or Not to Spank - It isn't a Question!


Lots of parents who think quite strongly in spanking, and that it is an acceptable and useful way of discipline, just don't have any other productive tools.

I think they are also unaware of the fact that this approach of discipline will change who their child becomes as an adult.

Our aim and responsibility as parents, is to protect, enjoy and prepare our young children for their lives as adults - to equip them with the social and emotional skills and tools they will need in order to be effectively and happily integrated into society as well-adjusted adults. Getting spanked is not a skill or tool that comes in handy as an adult. It has no value in career, relationships, monetary security, or individuals abilities. In fact, the effects of it are clearly detrimental to all these areas.

Here's how:

Spanking is an EMOTIONAL punishment. The emotional and psychological damage is far a lot more painful and long-lasting than any physical discomfort.

No individual would be comfortable having someone hit him, and not being allowed, or able, to protect himself, defend himself, or retaliate in any way - no matter what he's carried out.

* Career and financial security:

A child who is spanked can create a variety of emotional baggage and issues - including resentment, low self-esteem, low self-image, feelings of unworthiness, humiliation, and a large number of additional. One doesn't have to look far to see the result of this on career prospects and attitude to finances.

* Personal Relationships:

The primary source of a young child's studying is the observation of his parents. They have an inbuilt instinct to copy the substantial adults in their lives - like a kitten has an instinct to chase a piece of string. They discover how to handle a assortment of emotions and life challenges by observing, absorbing, and copying the way their parents deal with these items. They learn how to relate to others from how their parents relate to other people. They discover how to react to disputes, disagreements and frustrations, by the way their parents do. They do this unconsciously. They do not have the mental or reasoning ability to distinguish among "parent versus child" and "me versus others" - they are programmed to copy.

I don't know of any responsible parent who allows their child to hit others. So, here's a point of view from the spanked child's perspective: Other people could hit me, but I might not hit other people = I am much less valued/ much less very important than other people = watch that self-esteem hit the floor, along with self-value and self-respect.

This can generate an adult who attracts relationships (each personal and organization) with consumers who will treat them in the way they think they deserve (I am inferior to other people, and deserve to be treated as such).


The spanked child can develop resentment, anger issues, and (rather understandably) violence tendencies. (Would you be comfy with someone hitting you, and not becoming allowed, or able, to guard your self, defend yourself, or retaliate in any way?)
This could mean he becomes the aggressor in relationships.

Neither of these results are desirable of course.

* Consumers Abilities

One of the most beneficial, useful, and at times critical, attributes an adult can acquire, is the capability to get along with others, and to be able to function with, and communicate well with, other many people. Getting spanked, as you can imagine, contributes absolutely nothing to the development of this skill. In truth, it retards it. Having your parents demonstrate that the way to get what you want is to resort to hitting, indicates that they are not demonstrating all the other (additional beneficial and helpful) tools and abilities for affecting the outcomes you want.

"It's a final resort!" - Is it okay to resort to decking your neighbour "as a last resort" when he is rude/ defiant/ stubborn etc? Would a court of law accept your slapping the cashier in the supermarket simply because she swore at you and even known as you rude names? Don't forget, 1 of your key aims is to prepare your child to be integrated effectively into society as an adult.

You could possibly say, but this is my child not an adult. Yes, it is a human child, not a puppy or a cub. Animals discipline their young working with physical punishment considering that that is the only tool they have. But as humans we have been given the energy of reason and sophisticated communication - we should really not only make the most of it in disciplining our kids, but at the very same time, demonstrate to them how they can use it. They're watching!

Many many youngsters are well-disciplined without the use of physical punishment. It is not that "it's a last resort" - it's that it's the final resort you presently have. You will need to get some more resorts
You just will need to collect additional suggestions, tools and skills.

"But spanking works!" Does it certainly? By what are you measuring this good results? Is success that your youngsters are in fear of physical punishment, and for that reason respond out of fear and possibly have a tendency, not so significantly to: not misbehave, but rather: aim to not get caught?
or... is good results that your kids voluntarily respond considering they are learning reason, respect, understanding, empathy and communication skills?

"It's the only thing that works with my kids!" - correction - it is the only factor you Presently know of that "works" with your children. Make it your mission to uncover alternatives.

"I was spanked and there's nothing wrong with me!" It may well be worth going by way of a couple of of the issues and challenges you have that you might not associate with spanking - see above - relationships, funds, career, self-esteem, friendships, etc. and so on.

We can contribute to our child's capacity to be financially, professionally and personally effective and secure as an adult. There are much more effective techniques to discipline youngsters - approaches that are not only extra productive in the short-term, but are also constructive and supportive in the lengthy-term.

Category Article , , , , , , , , , , ,

What's on Your Mind...

Diberdayakan oleh Blogger.

Arsip Blog